This May, SAANYS is proud to honor our 2011 statewide award winners. The SAANYS awards program highlights educators who are committed to students and learning and have been chosen by their colleagues and community as exemplars of exceptional school leadership.
These awards are given during a period of unprecedentedly toxic, and often misleading, attacks on public educators. Recently I wrote of the fallacy of the statement, often repeated by the governor and lieutenant governor, that New York is 34th nationwide in educational results. This number was based upon a dated census figure of limited relevance; one which did not consider the state or country of origin where one may have gone to school. The more thorough and relevant Education Week study of educational quality places New York 2nd nationwide.
Then came the next round of mailings by the Committee to Save New York, a group largely made up of wealthy bankers and real estate investors that practically accuses administrators of being thieves, but artfully crafts the mailings in innuendo and implication. A favorite ploy is to compare the governor’s salary (without consideration of benefits) to the compensation (salary and benefits) of the top third of superintendents, without disclosing the different basis of the comparison. We also hear those citing the comparison use the more broad-brush title of “administrator”’ when seeking to generate public animus directed at educators.
The latest salvo is an article that appeared in the April 4 edition of the New York Post entitled “Supervision Bloat Hikes Overhead of the Class.” It is alleged therein that “…the ranks of education administrators…” have grown 34 percent over the last fifteen years while student population declined 4.6 percent during that time period. During the same time period, states the article, teacher positions increased 9.8 percent. A Cuomo spokesperson described the “…huge growth in school bureaucracy…” as “disturbing.”
This data is not new, but is presented in a misleading manner. In April 2010, E.J. McMahon, a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute and director of research at the Public Policy Institute (the research arm of the Business Council of NYS), wrote that between 2000-01 and 2008-09 New York schools added 14,746 teachers and 8,655 non-teaching professionals such as administrators, guidance counselors, nurses, psychologists, and social workers. The Post lumps all these titles into the generic phraseology of “education administrators.” McMahon noted that nearly half of the new staff members were hired in New York City, where Mayor Bloomberg was advocating for reduced class size. These explanations did not make it into the Post article, nor did the Post include an analysis of the state and federal mandates that have necessitated the increased staffing in areas such as special education.
For the most part, the recent public discourse on education issues is superficial, and many participants are not interested in real analysis but rather are engaged in advocacy. They stand in marked contrast to our award winners, for whom substance is a necessity and posturing a distraction.
Read Full Post »
You must be logged in to post a comment.